News Analysis: 79 Records Requests in 16 Months – Fullerton Gadfly Keeps City Clerk’s Office Busy

Email
Facebook
Twitter
Reddit
By:Matthew Cunningham

From May 2, 2025, to Oct. 12, 2026, a single Fullerton council gadlfy filed 79 requests with the City Clerk’s office under the California Public Records Act. That is more than one a week, every week, for 16 months.

The requester is Elijah Manassero, a twentysomething political activist and council gadfly who runs a political action committee called Fullerton Transparency. He also writes for the Fullerton Observer. In July, he announced at a City Council meeting that a recall had been launched against Mayor Fred Jung and Councilmember Jamie Valencia, and was on hand to video Jung when the mayor was ambushed in the Orange County Power Authority parking lot by a man serving him recall papers.

No other individual requester comes close to matching Manassero’s blizzard of public record requests.

The group’s website says Fullerton Transparency “is dedicated to shining a light on the decisions that shape our city.” It promises to break down complex policies, track political influence and give residents clear, accessible information “so that Fullerton’s future is guided by its people, not by special interests.” However, it’s actual focus appears to be relentlessly bashing Jung, Valencia and Dunlap.

The city’s log of Manassero’s requests points the same way. Ten of the 79 name Jung directly. Others seek the emails, texts or communications of Councilmembers Jaime Valencia and Nick Dunlap – also frequent targets of Manassero’s political ire.. Several target Tony Bushala, a developer and political donor whom Manassero and other critics have tied to the council majority.

Bursts of Requests

The requests often come in clusters. On Dec. 10, 2025, Manassero filed seven requests in one day. Most dealt with the city’s CalPERS appeal. One sought communications between Jung and Dunlap about the firing of former City Manager Ken Domer. Another asked for a former employee’s resignation letter. The next day he filed three more, about cannabis regulations and the Bushala family.

Some requests ask for records that would take staff many hours to find and review. One asked for every email, text message and Zoom chat that Jung, Valencia and Dunlap sent or received on the day of a single council meeting. It also asked for their correspondence with Bushala and another man over 30 days, and for sworn declarations from the people who keep the records describing how they searched. Another asked for a full year of monthly bank reconciliations for every city bank account, along with the city’s vendor master file and a log of every change to it.

The Trivial and The Curious

Other requests are harder to connect to any question of public accountability:

Fireworks lottery winners. On June 27, 2026, Manassero asked for records showing every contestant and winner in the city’s Safe and Sane fireworks sales lottery from 2020 to 2026. The City Clerk’s office runs that lottery itself. The same day, he asked for every communication by council members about Safe and Sane fireworks since 2020.

A decade-old youth football burglary. On Sept. 26, 2026, he filed an eight-part request about equipment thefts from the Fullerton Bears Football & Cheer youth organization in 2016, and a theft reported around June 9, 2018, at Ralph B. Clark Regional Park. He asked for incident numbers, whether any suspects were identified, arrested or prosecuted, and whether any property was recovered.

A records request about a records request. On March 4, 2026, Manassero asked for the city’s policies on handling public records requests. The next day he filed another request seeking the city’s internal communications about how staff were handling the first one.

The log also includes requests for council emails containing the words “Rosa Parks,” a list of new parks opened since 2021, and the ordinance setting planning commissioners’ pay.

Legal Deadlines, Limited Staff

The Public Records Act gives any person the right to inspect public records, and the requester does not have to explain why they want them. Agencies must decide within 10 days whether they have records that can be disclosed. They can extend that by up to 14 days only in unusual circumstances. Requesters generally pay only the cost of copies, not the staff time spent finding, reviewing and redacting records. That cost falls on taxpayers.

Fulfilling requests often means pulling staff from other departments. The Police Department handles police records. Finance handles bank and vendor files. Council members must search their own accounts and devices. The City Clerk’s office coordinates all of it.

That office 2.5 employees – the city clerk, the deputy city clerk and an administrative assistant shared with the city manager’s office – and has plenty of other legally required work. According to the city, those duties include:

  • Preparing City Council agendas and minutes
  • Serving as city’s elections officer
  • Maintaining the council’s legislative history
  • Running the citywide records management program
  • Running the Safe and Sane fireworks sales lottery
  • Maintaining the Fullerton Municipal Code
  • Ensuring compliance with the Brown Act and the Public Records Act
  • Receiving claims and other legal papers served on the city
  • Serving as filing officer for campaign finance statements and conflict-of-interest (Form 700) filings
  • Administering oaths of office
  • Certifying copies of official records
  • Keeping the city seal

The Clerk is also the elections official for the recall Manassero announced, so the same office must process the recall paperwork from the effort he helped launch.

Manassaro presents himself as a champion of good and efficient government, yet his hyperactivity in submitting public record requests without rhyme or reason serve to gum up the gears of government.

Transparency or Political Warfare?

Not every request is frivolous. Some dealt with real problems, including the city’s CalPERS violations over hiring retired officials and a $2.9 million transfer the city made to the wrong fund in 2022.

But the Public Records Act exists to let the public see how government works. It wasn’t designed to be a tool of opposition research. Taken as a whole, the 16-month log shows a pattern: requests filed in bursts, concentrated on the same three council members and their perceived allies, and often reaching back years in search of something. It is hard to escape the conclusion that many were driven by partisan suspicion more than by any specific evidence of wrongdoing, and that the process is being abused to serve partisan political vendettas.

Email
Facebook
Twitter
Reddit

Contact Us

Who is OC Independent?

The OC Independent is dedicated to providing factual, informative reporting on Orange County government, politics, education and quality of life issues such as homelessness and access to housing. We seek to illuminate aspects of issues, movements and trends that receive little or no attention from more established, mainstream outlets. Our editorial philosophy is grounded in the principles of the American Founding: limited government, federalism, the separation of powers and equality before the law as indispensable to securing our liberties. The opinions and stances articulated in OC Independent editorials flow from those principles, and are grounded in facts.